Who’s Keeping Score?

The new state report cards are out.  If you live in an inner ring suburb this brings a similar measure of dread as having  a root canal or finding out  that you have water pouring through the kitchen ceiling.  These state testing metrics are highly flawed and always tend to favor schools with higher income families and low diversity.  We can take some comfort in the fact that this newest round is so flawed that, according to Cleveland.com, “the Ohio Education Association, one of Ohio’s two largest teachers unions, said people should view the grades with ‘considerable caution.’ OEA President Becky Higgins reminded people that the scores are based on tests from PARCC, the multi-state testing consortium that Ohio fired in July.”

Nonetheless, our SEL Schools received  “A” grades for value added, gifted value added, and special needs value added, and an overall grade of C, which according to an article that ran today in Cleveland.com, is now the most common grade received, with the number of districts receiving “A” grades dropping from 37 to 6.

The metrics used for state report cards falls far short of telling the whole story of a school district.  Yet school rankings, no matter how flawed, will be touted by media outlets, tweeted, posted on Facebook pages, and spread like the plague across the region, creating winners and losers, and sealing the fate of communities.  The internet trolls will be at it again, tearing down diverse schools and making cringe-worthy comments.

The real story can’t be found in a score.  It’s told through the stories of the families, students, and teachers that make up a district. We plan to keep telling them.

2 thoughts on “Who’s Keeping Score?

  1. Like the article and agree that it’s not possible to measure all elements of useful education by universal metrics. As an active member in the local Historical Society I’m perturbed that local history gets left of the “teaching to the test” mentality mandated by trying to get better grades on these imbalanced report cards.
    I was surprised and disappointed to see a Jet Blue airline ad at the bottom of the article and learned we get these ads because it’s hosted on a “free” WordPress site and question whether paying for the site would be prohibitively expensive to not have ads here.

    Like

    1. Bob:

      Since this blog is a self-funded venture, we had to use a free platform to keep costs down. We are planning to do some fundraising outreach although we were sadly turned down by the Legacy Village Community Fund. We agree that our local history would certainly enrich our history curriculum. Thanks for all your do to promote the rich history of our community.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s